The moment of truth is here. Deanna Marcum has just responded [pdf] to On the Record: Report of The Library of Congress Working Group on the Future of Bibliographic Control.
« Palinet symposium on the future of cataloging | Main | More future of cataloging conversation... »
Tuesday, June 03, 2008
Comments
You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.
The comments to this entry are closed.
Search
Scope of blog
- The focus of this blog is the future of cataloging and metadata in libraries.
July 2014
| Sun | Mon | Tue | Wed | Thu | Fri | Sat |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | ||
| 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 |
| 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 |
| 20 | 21 | 22 | 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 |
| 27 | 28 | 29 | 30 | 31 |
Popular Posts
- IT competencies for metadata librarians
- No catalogers, or, The chickens have come home to roost
- Where Will We Get Our Metadata in the Future?
- Where I Find My Inspiration These Days
- Upgrading Catalogers' Skill Set
- More Resources on Upgrading Catalogers' Skills
- Catalogs/Cataloging Memes
- Anecdote or Evidence in the Future of Cataloging/Catalogs Debate?
- Future of Cataloging and the Role of Reference Librarians
- OCLC WorldCat.org: A Useful Cataloging Tool
Recent Posts
- RDA Training Booklet
- Catalogers, metadata librarians, digital humanists and coding
- More on LC's Bibliographic Framework Initiative: Kevin Ford's presentation
- LC Bibliographic Framework Transition: Eric Miller's update forum
- CatalogingPractices website
- The Feral Cataloger blog
- The relevance of quality cataloging
- Cataloging Futures: change of focus a misstep
- Cataloging Futures takes a new direction
- Interesting post: CodeYear Catalogers
Recent Comments
- David Bigwood on Catalogers, metadata librarians, digital humanists and coding
- Kai Li on Catalogers, metadata librarians, digital humanists and coding
- Library Gyaan on CatalogingPractices website
- StacyJo on The relevance of quality cataloging
- Christine Schwartz on More on LC's Bibliographic Framework Initiative: Kevin Ford's presentation
- David Bigwood on More on LC's Bibliographic Framework Initiative: Kevin Ford's presentation
- Christine Schwartz on LC Bibliographic Framework Transition: Eric Miller's update forum
- David M on LC Bibliographic Framework Transition: Eric Miller's update forum
- Christine Schwartz on LC Bibliographic Framework Transition: Eric Miller's update forum
- Christine Schwartz on LC Bibliographic Framework Transition: Eric Miller's update forum
Categories
- balisageConference09
- AACR2
- Acquisitions
- ALA
- ALA2007
- ala2008
- ALA2010
- ALA2011
- ALAMW08
- ALAMW09
- ALAMW11
- ALAMW2008
- ALAMW2009
- ALAMW2011
- ALCTS
- American Library Association
- Archives
- ARL
- Arlene Taylor
- Authority control
- authority work
- Automatic metadata generation
- Barbara Tillett
- Batchloading
- Best practices
- BIBFRAME
- Bibliographic control
- Bibliographic records
- Bibliographic utilities
- biblios.net
- Blogs
- Books
- Cataloging
- Cataloging education
- cataloging humor
- cataloging tools
- Cataloguing
- Cataloguing education
- cataloguing tools
- Classification
- Code4Lib
- Code4Lib2008
- Code4Lib2009
- Conferences
- CONSER
- Controlled vocabularies
- Curation
- David Bade
- DCMI
- Descriptive metadata
- Diane Hillmann
- Digital culture
- Digital humanities
- Digital libraries
- Digital Library Federation
- Digital objects
- Dublin Core
- Ebooks
- Embedded metadata
- ER diagrams
- Faviki
- Findability
- FRAD
- FRBR
- FRSAD
- full-text searching
- Future of cataloging
- Future of cataloguing
- Future of libraries
- HTML
- ICOLC
- IFLA
- ILS
- Information architecture
- Interlibrary loan
- International collaboration
- Internet Archive
- interoperability
- Janet Swan Hill
- JISC
- Karen Calhoun
- Karen Coyle
- LCSH
- Libary catalogs
- LibLime
- Library catalogs
- Library of Congress
- Library of Congress classification
- Library of Congress subject headings
- Library school
- Library Thing
- Linked data
- LITA
- LYRASIS
- MARBI
- MARC
- MARC 21
- MarkLogic
- Martha Yee
- Metadata
- metadata aggregation
- Metadata crosswalks
- metadata humor
- metadata librarianship
- Metadata schemas
- metadata workflows
- METS
- Michael Gorman
- micro-blogging
- MOBIUS
- MODS
- NDSL Metadata Registry
- NISO
- OCLC
- ONIX
- Ontology
- OPAC
- Open data
- Open Library
- Open source
- OWL
- Patrick Wilson
- photo metadata
- Professional development
- programming
- Quote of the day
- R2 Consulting
- Rare book cataloging
- RDA
- RDA data model
- RDA Online
- RDA Toolkit
- RDF
- Reading
- Reference librarians
- Renee Register
- RESTful Web Services
- RLG
- Roy Tennant
- Scrum
- Semantic Web
- Serials cataloging
- shared data
- SKOS
- SkyRiver
- SOAP
- software development
- Special collections cataloging
- Standards
- Tag clouds
- Tagging
- Tags
- Talis
- Technical services
- TEI
- Theological librarianship
- Thomas Mann
- Topic maps
- URI
- User behavior
- Watson
- Web
- Web 2.0
- Web 3.0
- Web usability
- Webcasts
- WGFBC
- Wikipedia
- Wikis
- WoGroFuBiCo
- WorldCat Local
- XML
- XQuery
Future of Cataloging: Key Resources (to May 2008)
- Rethinking How We Provide Bibliographic Services for the University of California: Final Report: December 2005
- White Paper on the Future of Cataloging at Indiana University, January 15, 2006
- Deanna B. Marcum, The Future of Cataloging, January 16, 2005
- Karen Calhoun, The Changing Nature of the Catalog and its Integration with Other Discovery Tools: Final Report, March 17, 2006
- Library of Congress Professional Guild, Future of Cataloging (various articles including Thomas Mann's critique of the Calhoun Report)
- Library of Congress, Working Group on the Future of Bibliographic Control
- RDA: Resource Description and Access website
- Conference on Bibliographic Control in the New Millennium (Library of Congress), 2000
- Catalogers Learning Workshop (CLW)
- Standards (The Library of Congress)
- Dublin Core Metadata Initiative (DCMI)
- ONIX (Online Information Exchange)
- Resource Description Framework (RDF) / W3C Semantic Web Activity
- Karen Calhoun, Being a Librarian: Metadata and Metadata Specialists in the Twenty-first Century, December 2004
- PennTags /tag/cataloging
- ALCTS and the Future of Bibliographic Control: Challenges, Actions, and Values, January 4, 2007
- futurelib wiki
- IFLA, Functional Requirements for Bibliographic Records (FRBR)
- Blogs About Catalogs and Cataloging
- Minerva Shelved, Cataloger Call [blog post], April 5, 2007
- Planet Cataloging
- MARC Content Designation Utilization » MCDU Home
- IFLA, Functional Requirements for Authority Data: A Conceptual Model (FRAD)
- Karen Calhoun, "Economics and Organization of Bibliographic Data": Response to Background Paper, July 9, 2007
- Diane I. Hillmann, Adding New Skills to our Skillset, July 2007
- Martha M. Yee, Will The Response Of The Library Profession To The Internet Be Self-Immolation? July 2007
- IFLA, Statement of International Cataloguing Principles
- David Bade, Structures, standards, and the people who make them meaningful, May 9, 2007
- Diane I. Hillmann, Structures and Standards for Our Bibliographic Future, May 9, 2007 [ppt]
- Alan Danskin, "Tomorrow never knows": the end of cataloguing?, June 6, 2006
- Metadata Services, Cornell University Library
- Chris Oliver, Changing to RDA, 2007
- Ingrid Hsieh-Yee, Cataloging and Metadata Education: A Proposal for Preparing Cataloging Professionals of the 21st Century, April 2003
- On the Record: Report of the Library of Congress Working Group on the Future of Bibliographic Control, January 9, 2008
- Robert Wolven, In Search of a New Model, January 15, 2008
- CPSO, Library of Congress Subject Headings: Pre- vs.Post-Coordination and Related Issues, June 13, 2007
- Thomas Mann, "On the Record" but Off the Track, March 14, 2008
- Karen Coyle and Diane Hillmann, Resource Description and Access (RDA): Cataloging Rules for the 20th Century, January 2007
- Martha M. Yee's home page
- ALA - ALCTS website
- Committee on Cataloging: Description and Access (CC:DA)
- DCMI/RDA Task Group Wiki
- Norm Medeiros, The catalog's last stand, 2007
- Richard Gartner, Metadata for digital libraries: state of the art and future directions, April 2008
- Francis Miksa, The Genius of Library Cataloging and its Possible Future, March 6, 2006 [Audio file]
- Karen Markey, The Online Library Catalog: Paradise Lost and Paradise Regained?, January 2007
Well, I didn't give it a really thorough reading...but the thing I had the biggest problem with in the report, the suspension of RDA, clearly LC is not going to go along with, so I'm ok with the response.
I certainly think RDA seems to have problems, and I don't know that it will be perfect, or the right answer, but I think that it is definitely still worth pursuing.
Posted by: arkham | Wednesday, June 04, 2008 at 02:21 PM
I agree. I'm behind continued RDA development also. Now that I'm working with mostly non-MARC formats (I'm only working on one project that's using MARCXML and MARC 21) the need for a new content standard is very apparent to me. I have to say that I love AACR2 and I'm sure I'll refer back to it as a reference. AACR2 has a coherent structure and logic to it. I have a particular fondness for my dogeared library school copy of the 1988 revision with penciled in LCRI rule numbers!
Posted by: Chris Schwartz | Wednesday, June 04, 2008 at 02:39 PM